logo

800.626.0054

  Interface Consulting X Logo    
  • Home
  • About Interface
    • Overview
    • News and Press Releases
    • Case Studies
    • Interface Articles
    • Employment Opportunities
  • Expert Services
    • Construction Claims & Disputes
      • Construction Delay Claims
      • Labor Productivity Claims
      • Design and Construction Defect Claims
      • Force Majeure Claims
      • Acceleration Claims
      • Suspension and Termination Claims
      • Differing Site Conditions Claims
      • Change Claims
    • Construction Defects
    • CPM Schedule Analysis
      • Windows Analysis or Contemporaneous Period Analysis
      • Time Impact Analysis (TIA)
      • Collapsed As-Built
      • Impacted As-Planned
      • As-Planned vs. As-Built
    • Construction Management
      • Contract Administration
      • Implementation of Project Controls
      • Execution of Processes and Procedures
      • Change Management
      • Risk Management
    • Litigation & Arbitration
      • Prudence Evaluation Experts
      • International Arbitration Construction Experts
      • Labor Productivity Analysis Experts
      • Schedule Delay Experts
      • Damage Quantification Experts
      • Design & Construction Defects Experts
      • Acceleration Experts
      • Suspension & Termination Experts
      • Force Majeure Experts
      • Differing Site Conditions Experts
      • Construction Change Experts
      • Standard of Care
    • Project Advisory
      • Construction Readiness Assessment
      • Contracting Strategy Development
      • Cost Risk Assessment
      • Project Audit
      • Project Execution Planning
      • Project Framing
  • Industries Served
    • Buildings & Facilities
      • Buildings
        • Education
        • Government Buildings
        • Commercial Buildings
        • Retail
      • Healthcare
      • Entertainment, Sports & Convention Centers
      • Industrial & Manufacturing
      • Multifamily Housing & Hotels
        • Multifamily Housing
        • Hotels
    • Transportation & Infrastructure
      • Airports
      • Heavy Civil
      • Roads, Highways, Bridges & Rail
      • Utilities
      • Water & Wastewater Treatment
    • Oil & Gas Pipelines
      • Land Pipelines
      • Subsea Pipelines
    • Marine & Offshore Production
      • Offshore
      • Ports, Piers & Wharfs
      • Shipbuilding & Vessels
    • Power & Energy
    • Chemical & Petrochemical
    • LNG & NGL
    • Oil & Gas Processing
    • Refining
    • Megaprojects
  • Interface Experts
    • Sam Barakat, PE, Esq., PSP
    • Jacob P. Hammond, CST
    • Lisa Sumner Heard
    • Dennis R. Jasinski, Fellow – ICCP
    • Mohamed W. Khazragui
    • Angela E. Lopez
    • Karen P. Matthews
    • Nicholas V. Ninan
    • Gabriel Paglicawan
    • Tapan Patni
    • Christopher J. Sullivan
    • Philip D. Barnard, PE
    • David Frinsco
    • Michael T. Gunter, PE, EVP
    • Chad P. Kirlin, PE, PMP
    • Greg Lamberson
    • Pete D. Luan, PMP
    • Charles W. Miller
    • Carolyn L. Morgan, CPA
    • Sean P. Pellegrino, PE
    • Leslie Rucker, CSP
    • Rodney Crawford, CPA
    • Kip Hamilton, CPA, CFE
    • Joel Murovitz, LEED AP
  • Contact Us
  • Client Login
  • Home
  • About Interface
    • Overview
    • News and Press Releases
    • Case Studies
    • Interface Articles
    • Employment Opportunities
  • Expert Services
    • Construction Claims & Disputes
      • Construction Delay Claims
      • Labor Productivity Claims
      • Design and Construction Defect Claims
      • Force Majeure Claims
      • Acceleration Claims
      • Suspension and Termination Claims
      • Differing Site Conditions Claims
      • Change Claims
    • Construction Defects
    • CPM Schedule Analysis
      • Windows Analysis or Contemporaneous Period Analysis
      • Time Impact Analysis (TIA)
      • Collapsed As-Built
      • Impacted As-Planned
      • As-Planned vs. As-Built
    • Construction Management
      • Contract Administration
      • Implementation of Project Controls
      • Execution of Processes and Procedures
      • Change Management
      • Risk Management
    • Litigation & Arbitration
      • Prudence Evaluation Experts
      • International Arbitration Construction Experts
      • Labor Productivity Analysis Experts
      • Schedule Delay Experts
      • Damage Quantification Experts
      • Design & Construction Defects Experts
      • Acceleration Experts
      • Suspension & Termination Experts
      • Force Majeure Experts
      • Differing Site Conditions Experts
      • Construction Change Experts
      • Standard of Care
    • Project Advisory
      • Construction Readiness Assessment
      • Contracting Strategy Development
      • Cost Risk Assessment
      • Project Audit
      • Project Execution Planning
      • Project Framing
  • Industries Served
    • Buildings & Facilities
      • Buildings
        • Education
        • Government Buildings
        • Commercial Buildings
        • Retail
      • Healthcare
      • Entertainment, Sports & Convention Centers
      • Industrial & Manufacturing
      • Multifamily Housing & Hotels
        • Multifamily Housing
        • Hotels
    • Transportation & Infrastructure
      • Airports
      • Heavy Civil
      • Roads, Highways, Bridges & Rail
      • Utilities
      • Water & Wastewater Treatment
    • Oil & Gas Pipelines
      • Land Pipelines
      • Subsea Pipelines
    • Marine & Offshore Production
      • Offshore
      • Ports, Piers & Wharfs
      • Shipbuilding & Vessels
    • Power & Energy
    • Chemical & Petrochemical
    • LNG & NGL
    • Oil & Gas Processing
    • Refining
    • Megaprojects
  • Interface Experts
    • Sam Barakat, PE, Esq., PSP
    • Jacob P. Hammond, CST
    • Lisa Sumner Heard
    • Dennis R. Jasinski, Fellow – ICCP
    • Mohamed W. Khazragui
    • Angela E. Lopez
    • Karen P. Matthews
    • Nicholas V. Ninan
    • Gabriel Paglicawan
    • Tapan Patni
    • Christopher J. Sullivan
    • Philip D. Barnard, PE
    • David Frinsco
    • Michael T. Gunter, PE, EVP
    • Chad P. Kirlin, PE, PMP
    • Greg Lamberson
    • Pete D. Luan, PMP
    • Charles W. Miller
    • Carolyn L. Morgan, CPA
    • Sean P. Pellegrino, PE
    • Leslie Rucker, CSP
    • Rodney Crawford, CPA
    • Kip Hamilton, CPA, CFE
    • Joel Murovitz, LEED AP
  • Contact Us
  • Client Login

Megaprojects – Mega Disaster or Disaster Preventer

by Bennett Coleman
International ArbitrationFebruary 26, 20200 comments

By Frank G. Adams, PE, President and Principal Consultant, Interface Consulting International

Megaprojects were historically considered construction projects that cost more than $1 billion. However, recent megaprojects, particularly large-scale public works and infrastructure projects, often exceed $10 billion. Megaproject owners, and associated engineers, and contractors are using innovative project delivery strategies to contain costs, mitigate risk, manage delays, and reduce disputes. A variable delivery strategy is being used to balance risks with contract compensation. While not new to the construction industry, this concept can be particularly useful in reducing claims and disputes on megaprojects.

Historically, owners mandated fixed-price turnkey construction contracts. However, as projects began to exceed $1 billion in cost, fewer contractors could bear the increased financial risks. It also became more difficult to pass certain risks to subcontractors and suppliers, who were often smaller and less capable of managing that risk. With megaproject owners experiencing dwindling interest from EPC firms whose knowledge and resources were vitally needed, owners chose to reduce the requirement of fixed-price contracting.

Megaprojects are now using variable, or hybrid, compensation provisions with elements of fixed pricing, unit pricing, and cost-reimbursable compensation contract formats. Construction contracts can thus allocate risk to the party best able to manage that risk. For example, some contracts use lump sum for engineering and construction management services, while the direct cost of construction subcontracts may be cost reimbursable or unit rate if the contractor has sufficient information at bid to properly estimate construction costs. Additionally, when material or labor pricing is highly volatile, an owner may use a cost-reimbursable contract structure rather than ask for lump-sum bids that may contain excessive contingency to cover that risk. Hybrid compensation structures allow for a wider participation of contractors who otherwise might decline to bid due to the perceived high risk associated with fixed lump-sum pricing.   

Megaprojects may experience significant cost increases and schedule delays over initial estimates, but when variable compensation and proper risk allocation are the basis of construction, the projects are less likely to result in large claims and costly disputes. When disputes do arise, the variable compensation alternatives provide a framework for resolution, preventing a megaproject from becoming a mega disaster.

To learn more, contact Frank Adams fgadams@interface-consulting.com.

Released: February 26th, 2020 08:58 AM

View Full Article »
Expert Hot Tubbing – Litigators, It's Coming Your WayPrev

Categories

CONTACT US

To find out how our Construction Consultants and Experts can assist you, or for other inquiries, please call 800.626.0054 or

EMAIL US NOW

The views expressed in this article are those of the author(s) and not necessarily the views of Interface Consulting, its management, or its other professionals.

logo

Interface Consulting provides a portfolio of professional support services to a wide range of clients including owners, contractors, attorneys, engineers, insurers, and suppliers involved in the engineering and construction process.

Quick Links

  • About Interface
  • Industries Served
  • News & Press Releases
  • Interface Articles
  • Interface Experts
  • Employment Opportunities
  • Client Login

Expert Services

  • Construction Claims & Disputes
  • Construction Defects
  • Construction Management
  • CPM Schedule Analysis
  • Litigation & Arbitration
  • Project Advisory

Corporate Office

  • Interface Consulting International, Inc.
  • 5847 San Felipe Street, Suite 1910
  • Houston, TX 77057
  • contact@interface-consulting.com
  • 800.626.0054(Phone)
  • 713.626.2555 (Fax)
  • Get Directions
  • Branch Offices
  • Naples, Florida
       
  • Interface Consulting
  • Terms of Use
  • Privacy Statement
  • Site built with Port City Media.